"CSEARCH" and "nmrshiftdb.org"


Quality check of nmrshiftdb-data using CSEARCH-Algorithms:


Procedure:



March 10th, 2007:



March 11th, 2007 / lunchtime:



Result:   Average deviation:   2.22ppm

(before any correction applied)



Comparison before correction

March 11th, 2007 / afternoon; after 2 hours of work:

Average deviation is now: 2.19ppm


After data correction


Summary of data quality:




Original version

After data-correction; Error-detection using CSEARCH-algorithms

Functional groups

804

801

Average range per functional group

23.16ppm

21.00ppm

Outliers/25ppm:

194

190

Outliers/50ppm:

56

45

Average deviation/NN,stereo=ON

2.22ppm

2.19ppm corresponds to ca. 6,200ppm overall

Total number of assigned carbons

209412

209425



What has been done to the original data:



This small improvement - which is far away from being perfect and/or complete - without the use of one, single literature citation improves the assignment quality by ca. 6,200 ppm !




Keep in mind:




But:   Enjoy - it's free !



In accordance with the original page, here is the

'Hall of fame'   ;-))


Hall of fame


A few facts about CSEARCH/NMRPredict and NMRShiftDB


A remark by Antony Williams from CHEMSPIDER/ACD stating that only 250 errors are within these data - the verification has been done by the ACD-Predictor-Software. Peter Murray-Rust - a well known expert in the field of NMR-spectrum prediction - also tries to convince the scientific community from the superior quality of NMRShiftdb and its verification by ACDlabs. My more detailed investigation shows that there are definitely more than 250 errors as stated by Antony Williams. Furthermore some severe problems within the software itself have been identified - but it's free !


Page written by Wolfgang Robien / March 12th, 2007
email:    Wolfgang.Robien(at)univie.ac.at